That fender is far from a 600 dollar fender, it needs a lot of work and for that price you could get a reproduction. Like I said before, I sold a perfect fender on eBay last summer for around 750(when repos were a long time away)...when I say perfect I mean it was completely stripped, hammer and dollied, and had hours of work into it, that fender just needed to be bolted up and given the once over. The fender on eBay is a good starting point, but certainly isnt worth that much.