Yeah, I've seen other reviews of their stuff that was less than impressive, including the headlight buckets, which I mentioned earlier. On the other hand, if you don't have 300 bones for a metal pair, its at least some kind of option.
Since its fiberglass and mostly not visible, you could probably "make them fit" and strengthen them up if need be and still come out ahead on price, fiberglass is pretty cheap.
Obviously if "show" quality is needed the only way to go is a metal pair, either new or from a "patch" quality set of old fenders.