So you are saying with the race installed, and not with the carrier, the main cap will not pull down square and flat? Is this true to both sides or just one side (ring gear) The cap may of been damaged and spread. If someone local with rear end experience could look at it, that would be helpfull, but machining them down yourself will make the gap larger. If there was a breakage problem before you got this unit, I might would just find another center to use. What number housing are you useing? Pictures would also help