I'll give a story with this one for effect...
I ordered some fenders that were in decent shape. Driver was advertised as rougher than passenger. I cut them open enough to make sure I got them and took them to the blaster the next day with the car but never had them out of the packaging they came in. It was obvious when I got the car back that I had goofed by not looking them over more carefully... and here is the result.
So uh... anyone need a 68 RR fender?!