I would make sure that the tank is not leaking from the sending unit on the side of the tank. From what I recollect, some people prefer to use the old lock ring as the new ones don't seal as well.
When you saw the leak, was the tank topped off? Was the puddle on the driver's side of the tank?
As far as I remember for a '72 tank , there is no drainplug on the top. There are 6 openings: sending unit hole on the side, gas tube inlet and 4 vent nipples. Doe you have all 4 hoses hooked up?
Make sure you know what general area the gas is leaking from.