The one I have is a driver's side. If it is not rusted out, I would hammer it back into shape. That's what I did to mine. It was hit at the top just above the wheel lip. When I cut the quarter off, I hammered it back into shape. Even if it is not absolutely perfect, it will be fine because you can't see it even once the quarter is put back on. Just make sure the attaching edge that goes to the quarter wheel lip is tight so you can get a good plug weld.