One thing to consider when having the originals replated, if you need some tweaking or straightening done they will need to have a good template to work from. Ideally the car they will be fitted too as prodution tolerances, time, and "abuse" can cause things to vary.
I had the plating popped off at a bolt hole also, but I think that was my fault for trying to make it fit right. If you use the bolt holes to pull the bumper in or out the distortion in that area can cause the chrome to crack and peel as it is brittle.
A little more expensive, but what I like about Year One is, they will always take items back and pay the shipping too.
