Ok so off idle yes you roots style is good, but can you drive on the street on low boost then pull into the track turn a knob and flip on the methanol switch and race on high boost with no tools? Don't think so, And if I'm planning an off idle launch why wouldn't I build boost on the line? that takes the advantage right away from your roots, and they make intercoolers to cool the air so your engine is not ingesting hot air. Plus the op asked about methanol which will cool the intake charge even more. With all the turbos available today lag is not really a factor you can choose one for low end torque or for high end power depending on the purpose of the car. I can send you a few articles on turbos if you'd like. Lol like I said earlier its opinion based some people like superchargers others like turbos. Personally I like the ability to raise or lower power (boost) with the turn of knob. When I race/drive hard I launch in boost and don't experience "lag"