Just got home and had a chance to speak with the wife.
Turns out the guy was driving a 2500 (my wife drives a 1500).
She does not see how she broke the light on the top of his mirror. Apparently it had a hole in, not just cracked.
My wife says there was dirty water in the light and she does not think she broke it. Unfortunately, my wife is not the confrontational type, so she did not say anything to the guy.
Apparently, when she got out of the truck, she said I think I hit your mirror, the guy said, yeah no big deal. Then after pumping gas he noticed the "damage".
Looks like it will be an interesting time.
If my wife damaged the truck, I have no problem paying, or having my insurance paying, but if not, I am not fixing the guys truck.
Jason