I got the year one ralleys late last year, they look awesome! My car has stock suspension, old and in moderate disrepair
I ended up going with the 17x8's all around for a few reasons, I preferred to use a 50 series tire to maximize tire sidewall height both for looks and ride quality instead of something like 275/40's, so the 17x9's didn't seem necessary. I think I also read somewhere on here that the 17x9's may result in some possible front end clearance issues on the inside edge.
For tires I got Kumho Ecsta ESP 235/50 front and 255/50 rear. I think they look pretty good and they have the correct weight rating for the car. 235/50 was about as tall a tire it seemed would fit up front, and 255/50 allowed me to get a bit more width in back without having too much difference in size front to back. Would have preferred to run the same size all around, but again its all trade off's for one reason or another based on personal preference.
Ultimately I'm happy with the choices. I had to raise the front a bit to make the fit, but I think I still have some room left on the outside to upgrade to disc brakes, which need a little extra room. The driver side rear is very close to the wheel well, but so far so good. The rear leaf's are old and will be replaced eventually so I'll have a little more room at that time...