New panels have an attraction if you can afford them, however I will say up front that while the steel will be new, it will never fit as well as what you have. I replaced complete rear quarters, 1 door skin and both fenders because I had no choice. I spent a lot of time making it fit and if you are going to pay someone to fit the panels and paint the car, it could be more expensive than repairing what you have. that said, good research and thinking it through it worth the time to determine the best course of action.