As someone who has been looking for a 72-74 Rallye Challenger for almost a year now, it's a tad bit high, IMHO. I am looking at one near me, very similar shape to yours except older paint, for $4500. I am going to offer $3500, but I will pay $4500. I apprenticed as a mechanic, and worked in a body shop, and I know how much it costs to restore a car. It's not cheap. I am also good with money and have never overspent on the 40+ Mopars I have owned. Your car is a nice driver, definately not a basket case, but needs a bit of work. Realistically, you should get between $5000-$7500. I have watched your ad, and you had it on Ebay(?) too. Hopefully, you have room to bring the price down and it will sell! There's 2 cents worth....