I've used valley pans several times, mostly at the track, trying different manifolds/carb set ups. Since you're having a problem it would be best to get a new Fel-Pro set ( PN# 1214 ) that comes with the pan and two paper gaskets. Then use RTV sealer around the ports and on the bolt threads.
If you think you still have a problem, get it at a steady idle and set up a tach. Then use some propane around the intake or any other areas that could leak vacuum. You'll notice the RPM's increase from the fuel ( propane ) if you hit a leak spot. Don't forget to check vacuum lines to any other areas like brake boosters, cruise controls, climate controls.
Good Luck!