Ok, I'm messed up......UGH.......after I posted those last pics I decided to start breaking down the rest of the stuff, well that's when I noticed the shaft that I was SUPPOSED to sand and realized I sanded the wrong one.
Here's pics of the one you wanted me to sand. Before and after. The front was extremely torn up. I had to use 80 grit to get it smooth, then used 150, then 400 to smooth it all over. The rear though wasn't coming out like you explained. I took the snap ring off and put a penny over the shaft and tapped, tapped, then banged and banged harder and nothing. The shaft didn't move, so I decided to sand it in place. I got most of it smooth, but as you can see, there is still some rough areas.
My work is done for tonight, I'll be back at it on Friday morning. Tomorrow night I'm off to shoot pool in my league.