It is possible to gear too high (low numerically) to suit your engine, depending on its state of tune. Most cars get their best fuel economy while running in the fat part of their torque curve. On the limited info I have, I would think 2500 should be pretty good for mpg. This can vary widely according to cam etc. I had a Dodge w/ 400 ci eng that only got 13.5 when running 55 to 60 mph, but got 16.5 running 75. I verified this several times. It had 2.71 gears & 15' wheels. Also, average throttle position has a large effect on mpg, but I know that none of you guys run you cars hard. (HEE-HEE!!!)