My race car with 500 hp (not much) and slicks on a sticky staring line tore those gears up. Rips them right off of the ring or pinion. My car was only 2300 lbs. Put a DANA in it and ran for 8 more years till I sold it.
In my opinion, you need a DANA. Stroker, you are right on the verge of blowing up that puny 8-3/4. They will only hold up till you get some serious traction, them BOOOOM!
Rob