Here are pictures of my 3 speaker AC dash from ultimate rides. I will try to be accurate about my experience. First the Good - the grain on the pad (although not exact to orginal) is very good, the center speaker with just minor trimming fit well and the Barracuda name plate indention is the correct size, The bad - It took me almost 2 hours to scrape of all the excess foam that was sprayed on the metal pad frame on the underside, there was so much on there that it was holding the pad off the dash frame, the studs on the dashpad aer not in the best of shape and I had to chase them to get them to work, the ac vents do not fit well at all as you can see from the gap in the pictures, I had to wait almost 4 months to get the pad and then another 2 months to get my core deposit back ( I must have called them 20 times) The Ugly - the plastic trim that goes on the drivers side is so far off I don't know how to fix it. The basic problem is that the pad is too thick and will not allow the trim to fit over it.
With all that said, I am not sure whats a better alternative but I would hope that the quality improves.