This page has a lot of good Gator Grain info;
http://www.cledawgshome.com/gatorgraintop.htmI have not seen a sample of the new Legendary top, but the sample in the original color & trim selector looked black to me until I placed a weathered piece from a well worn top next to it.
If Legendary did it right, the brown dye is not even, the original tops have a marbled, brownish-black appearance. Kind of an overall brown with black showing through, it is hard to describe.
So, some small samples may appear to be more one way that the other.