ok, i totally agree with you mike, its a bunch of crap.,,
so the details are, 1999 saturn sc2, 1.9L dohc, 5 sp.
the only other symptom is on occassion when coming to a stop the idle drops to below 500 rpm and seems like its going to stall, then quickly revovers.
as for carbon build up, i see it a "normal" all the passages were slightly built up but not enough to restrict flow.
as for the valvue, it is a 5 pin.
Over all its been a good commuter car with 38 mpg and i drive approximately 80 miles round trip daily most of which is highway. other than routine maintenance the only thing i ever had t do was replace the clutch, that was no fun becquse you have to pull the engine out completely, fortunately i have everything you need to do that surgurcial procedure.
So, today I'll pull the valve out clean it up again, clean the connection pins reinstall and clear the code.
After that, well,,,,,,,,,,, I'll let you know.
Thank you everyone for all the iinfo.