I would go 2.5 inch and then put a reducer at the tip. That's what I did on my Challenger. TTI offers complete manifold back kits, but I believe they are for only high performance manifolds, like 440, hemi and 70 340, but may be wrong. I have not installed the magnaflow header back kit for the Challenger, but did for a cuda and their kit is not designed for stock tips, it is designed to use the tips they provide and dump below the valance. Not sure if the Challenger kit is easier to deal with due to the location of the factory tips, but I'll bet work would have to be done to the tailpipes to utilize the stock tips. Other than that I loved the 2.5 kit I installed in the cuda.