If it was me, I'd pull and look, before I just stuck a new one in. The new lifter on an old cam? That's exactly how you HAVE to do it. The cam wears to the lifter. Used lifters on a new cam will destroy it. New lifters on a used cam will seat again. But you should go thru the same cam break in even if it's onlt one lifter. So that means making sure it rotates in the bore, adding break in lube, running it at 1800 for 20 minutes, leaving out the inner spring if you have true doubles... I had a 440 that bent two pushrods during spirited driving... but low rpm. I was younger, but I just stuck new pushrods in and it was ok. I was less cynical and a lot younger then...lol