To be honest, I dont think I can make a good call there.
My panels had been sanded in places and had several coats of dye/paint on them.....seems like where the panels meet the grain matches well, but again, tough to call.
The ydo seem to match the dyed replacement kickpanels I got at Carlisle.....they were originally green and I dyed them black. Didnt compare side by side out of the car...just as-installed.
I know I really like the way they look!
My wife, when she saw them on the first time , said "Wow!" lol
Really cleaned up the doors.....now I need the rears and then a-pillars.