Well for starters I should clarify I bought a used Z06 and paid less than a new Challenger (paid under $30k for it) price for it. For the price of a new Challenger SRT8 I can build a classic challenger with XV motorsports suspension brakes, drop in a fuel injected engine, overdrive, etc, etc, and made it destroy a new challenger. but that is not the discussion.
I'm not saying the new Challenger is a bad car in the way it performs or that it is uncomfortable, I am saying that the body porportions are wrong and it looks like a bloated cow compared to the original. Also when I sit in a new challenger i get a feeling that I am in a new charger, not an old challenger. The new challenger is more like a modern sedan than a modern muscle car. The interior on the mustang and camaro are a lot better in terms of resemblance to the original than the challenger is. yes they have less interior room than the challenger, but they are muscle cars, not performance sedans. Most road tests of the 3 new cars places the challenger last, why because it is bigger, heavier, underpowered (for its size) and really other than appearance (by itself) is really a sedan and not a muscle car.