I don't think the console is cheesy. The black plastic texture and the "woodgrain" match the rest of the interior. No one ever said E-bodies had lavish interiors like a '57 DeSoto. If you think the console is lame, then you must think the rest of the interior is as well.....
I left the console out when I converted my Cuda from a Slap-Stik 727 to the Keisler 5-speed, but that is because the pistol grip is so damn cool I like to showcase it and not hide the boot with the console.
Console and Slap-Stik is definitely way cooler on automatics than the granny shifter on the column. I'm guessing the percentage of people who prefer the granny shifter is pretty small. To each their own, but I think the granny shifter sucks.