I have used the AEM UEGO sensor in a few turbo projects with the analog gauge. For tuning i don't think the analog gauge is necessarily beneficial, however for me personally when driving i like to get any idea of what the car is doing with a quick glance. So for me the analog needle gauge is easier than the digital readout. Then again, i have never liked digital dashes from the 80's either.
I have used an innovate setup before in the past with good results too.
For the challenger i will probably go with the AEM Failsafe for its ease of logging and adjustability, or the Analog UEGO again.