So far I have not been of any help
I can't come up with any plausible way that it could be that lean on the high side unless the sensor was mounted close to the open end of a collector and that is not the case.
In my experience with wb's I have found that they can get really flaky if the power and ground sides are not solid. You might try connecting the power directly to the battery for both + and - temporarily and see if that has any effect at all.
Perhaps before you do that, you might switch the sensor back to the side that seemed to be giving a reasonable reading and see if it repeats and works again.
Also, you might try using the software logworks that comes with it and see if the log shows the same numbers as you are seeing on the unit, itself.
Normally, I have had problems with the analog outputs while the digital side kept working properly.